Insurance Options of Florida (IOFLA) Joins the FEI Family
Longtime agency owner Tad Cromley joins the FEI team during the transition — all existing clients keep their coverage and service without interruption.
Florida Educators Insurance (FEI), one of Florida's leading independent insurance agencies, has acquired Insurance Options of Florida, a well-regarded Sarasota-area agency previously owned and operated by Tad Cromley. The transition, effective mid-July 2026, expands FEI's presence in Southwest Florida and reflects the agency's continued commitment to serving Florida families and professionals with personalized, independent insurance guidance.
A Trusted Name Grows Its Reach
Founded more than 22 years ago by Gary Cucchi, FEI has grown into one of Florida's most trusted independent agencies, earning more than 500 five-star Google reviews from clients across the Tampa Bay area and beyond. As an independent agency, FEI works on behalf of its clients — not insurance carriers — shopping multiple providers to make sure every policyholder gets the most competitive coverage for their individual needs.
Tad Cromley, who built strong relationships throughout the Sarasota community during his years running Insurance Options of Florida, will remain actively involved during and after the transition to ensure continuity of service for all existing clients.
“This acquisition is about bringing more resources and options to clients who already have a trusted relationship with Tad and his team. Our goal is simple: make sure every client in Sarasota has access to the same level of personalized service and expanded carrier options that FEI clients across Florida have come to expect.”
Cromley shares that enthusiasm for what's ahead:
“I’ve spent years building relationships with clients and carriers in this community, and I’m proud of what Insurance Options of Florida has become. Joining the FEI family means my clients don’t just keep the service they know — they gain access to a broader network and a team that has been doing this at the highest level for over two decades. I’m excited to be part of what comes next.”
What This Means for Existing Clients
Existing Insurance Options of Florida clients don't need to take any action. Current policies, coverage terms, and premium rates remain unchanged, and members of the FEI team will be reaching out directly to each client to introduce themselves and answer any questions about the transition.
The acquisition positions FEI to better serve educators, first responders, and families throughout Southwest Florida, building on its flagship operations in the Tampa Bay area.
About Florida Educators Insurance
Florida Educators Insurance is an independent insurance agency headquartered in the Tampa Bay area of Florida, serving clients statewide. Founded by Gary Cucchi over 22 years ago, FEI specializes in auto, home, life, supplemental, flood, watercraft, and commercial insurance for educators, first responders, Florida residents, and families. With more than 500 five-star Google reviews, the agency is known for its commitment to personalized service and its network of multiple carrier relationships that enable clients to receive competitive, tailored coverage.
For more information, visitfloridaeducatorsinsurance.com.
About Insurance Options of Florida
Insurance Options of Florida, formerly known as Cromley & Associates, has served the Sarasota community as a trusted independent insurance agency. Under the leadership of Tad Cromley, the agency developed strong ties with local families and businesses, offering personalized guidance across a range of personal and commercial insurance lines.
Media Contact: Gary Cucchi, Owner | (813) 600-3268 | floridaeducatorsinsurance.com